Fresh, Hand-Rolled Bagels in West Babylon, NY
We don’t just make bagels — we make mornings better.
Start your morning with West Babylon’s go-to spot for real New York bagels—made from scratch, baked to perfection, and served warm with your favorite cream cheese.
We proudly offer a 10% discount to all first responders and educators.
A Local Favorite for Over 25 Years
For more than 25 years, The Bagel Factory has been the neighborhood’s favorite bagel shop in West Babylon — serving authentic, hand-rolled bagels baked fresh every single morning.
Our bakers start before sunrise, crafting bagels the old-fashioned way for that signature New York bite — crisp on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside.
From everything and sesame to rainbow bagels and limited-edition flavors, every bagel is made fresh, with pride, care, and plenty of love.
Proudly made with quality ingredients you know and love.
Our Fresh-Baked Menu
More than just bagels — our menu is packed with breakfast and lunch favorites you’ll crave again and again.
From bacon-egg-and-cheese sandwiches to turkey clubs, wraps, paninis, salads, and seasonal specials, there’s something for everyone.
Order Your Favorites, Your Way
Enjoy your favorite bagels in West Babylon however you like — pickup, dine-in, or delivered right to your door.
Available on:
Breakfast, Lunch & Catering — Made Fresh for You
Whether you’re grabbing breakfast on the go, ordering lunch for the office, or hosting a weekend brunch, The Bagel Factory has you covered.
We serve breakfast and lunch daily with something for everyone — from hearty breakfast sandwiches and hot-pressed paninis to crisp salads and fresh wraps.
Planning an event? Our catering platters make meetings, parties, and gatherings deliciously simple. Whether you’re in West Babylon or nearby Lindenhurst, NY, we provide quality and flavor that keeps guests talking.
Limited-Time & Seasonal Flavors
We love to keep things fresh—literally!
Every season, we feature limited-time bagel varieties, cream cheese blends, and special breakfast or lunch creations inspired by what’s in season.
Check back often for our latest flavor drops and seasonal favorites!
Why Locals Choose Us
It’s not just about the bagels (though ours are pretty amazing) — it’s about the people we serve every day. Here’s why our neighbors keep coming back:
Over 20 Bagel Varieties, Baked Fresh Daily
Every bagel is hand-rolled and baked fresh each morning, so you can taste the difference in every bite.
15+ Cream Cheese Flavors (and Counting!)
From scallion to strawberry to seasonal spreads — there’s always something new to try.
Something for Everyone
Fuel up with breakfast sandwiches, lunch wraps, paninis, and salads.
5-Star Favorites
Don’t just take our word for it — see why hundreds of happy customers rave about us on Google Reviews and Facebook.
Craving the Best Bagels in West Babylon?
Stop by The Bagel Factory today. We’re open early every day for breakfast, lunch, and catering pickups.
- 615 W Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704
- 631-661-0011